VSTE
Littera Scripta

ISSN (online): 1805-9112

Research ArticleOpen access

Is CarSharing a profitable business model for automotive OEMs?

Aljoscha Groos1, Zuzana Stoličná1

  1. Comenius University Bratislava

Abstract

CarSharing is seen as one of the four major trends in the automotive industry. The ever-increasing traffic volume in large cities, easier access to digital services through smartphones and the change in people's ecological thinking are seen as drivers for this business segment. Nevertheless, the German car manufacturers BMW and Daimler, normally competitors in the market, have joined forces in a joint venture (ShareNow) in the hope of being finally profitable. The venture does not release any information about their business figures and also in the literature there is so far no detailed analysis of the costs for operating a Free-Floating CarSharing company. This article will therefore use the Munich-based company ShareNow as an example to determine the cost structure and examine the non-monetary benefits for car manufacturers in addition to the monetary side. The analysis indicates that this business cannot be operated profitably and that even considering the non-monetary benefits, remaining in this business segment is questionable.

Keywords:car sharingfree floatingautomotivebusiness modelcost structure

References

  1. ASSELIN-MILLER, N.; G. HORTON; S. AMARAL; H. FIGG; D. SHELDON; C. LUTZ; M. FLAUTE; P. WELLS, (2017). GEAR 2030 Strategy 2015-2017. Comparative analysis of the competitive position of the EU automotive industry and the impact of the introduction of autonomous vehicles: final report. European Union. Available online at https://op.europa.eu/s/oFl0, checked on 1/21/2021.
  2. BARDHI, F.; G. M. ECKHARDT, (2012). Access-Based Consumption: The Case of Car Sharing. In Journal of Consumer Research, 881–898.
  3. BELK, R., (2014). You are what you can access: Sharing and collaborative consumption online. In Journal of Business Research, 1595–1600.
  4. CORNET, A.; D. MOHR; F. WEIG; B. ZERLIN; A.-P. HEIN, (2012). Mobility of the future: Opportunities for automotive OEMs. McKinsey&Company (Advanced Industries). Available online at http://worldmobilityleadershipforum.com/wp- content/uploads/2016/04/Mobility_of_the_Future_Brochure-1.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  5. Automobilwoche, (2020). Corona-Krise: WeShare verschiebt Expansion. In Automobilwoche, 2020. Available online at https://www.automobilwoche.de/article/20200624/AGENTURMELDUNGEN/306249989/coro na-krise-weshare-verschiebt-expansion, checked on 1/21/2021.
  6. Süddeutsche Zeitung, (2020). Share Now soll schneller aus den roten Zahlen. In Sueddeutsche Zeitung, (2020). Available online at https://www.sueddeutsche.de/wirtschaft/auto-stuttgart- share-now-soll-schneller-aus-den-roten-zahlen-dpa.urn-newsml-dpa-com-20090101-200115- 99-484232, checked on 1/21/2021.
  7. ENGELS, E., (2019). Carsharing in München: Das sind die Pläne der Stadt. In Abendzeitung, 2019. Available online at https://www.abendzeitung-muenchen.de/muenchen/carsharing-in- muenchen-das-sind-die-plaene-der-stadt-art-473522, checked on 1/21/2021.
  8. FOLLMER, R.; J. BELZ, (2018). Mobilität in Deutschland – MiD Kurzreport Stadt München, Münchner Umland und MVV-Verbundraum. Studie von infas, DLR, IVT und infas 360 im Auftrag des Bundesministers für Verkehr und digitale. Available online at https://www.muenchen- transparent.de/dokumente/5499206/datei, checked on 1/21/2021.
  9. GOLDMANN, L., (2018). Carsharing - Verlust durch Teilen. In brand eins, 2018. Available online at https://www.brandeins.de/magazine/brand-eins- wirtschaftsmagazin/2018/mobilitaet/carsharing-verlust-durch-teilen, checked on 1/21/2021.
  10. HAWKINS, A. J., (2019). BMW and Daimler will spend over $1 billion on the future of transportation. In The Verge, (2019). Available online at https://www.theverge.com /2019/2/22/18235941/daimler-bmw-mobility-joint-venturebillion-dollars, checked on 1/21/2021.
  11. HELBIG, N.; J. SANDAU; J. HEINRICH, (2017). The Future of the Automotive Value Chain—2025 and Beyond. Deloitte. Available online at www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/us/Documents/consumer-business/us-auto-the- future-of-the-automotive-value-chain.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  12. HOHMANN, M., (2021). Durchschnittlicher Preis für Superbenzin in Deutschland in den Jahren 1972 bis 2021. Available online at https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/776/umfrage/durchschnittspreis-fuer- superbenzin-seit-dem-jahr-1972/, checked on 1/21/2021.
  13. HÜLSMANN, F.; J. WIEPKING; W. ZIMMER; F. HACKER; P. KASTEN; B. SCHMOLCK, (2018). share - Wissenschaftliche Begleitforschung zu car2go mit batterieelektrischen und konventionellen Fahrzeugen. Forschung zum free-floating Carsharing: Abschlussbericht. Berlin.
  14. IMMEN, S., (2020). Pessemitteilung Nr. 1/2020. Fahrzeugzulassungen im Dezember 2019 – Jahresbilanz – korrigierte Fassung. KBA. Available online at https://www.kba.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilungen/DE/2020/pm_01_2020_fahrzeugzulassu ngen_12_2019_pdf.pdf;jsessionid=962279BB450BC3BD680AAC7995BBFDB4.live11293?__blob= publicationFile&v=11, checked on 1/21/2021.
  15. KAAS, H.-W.; D. MOHR; P. GAO; N. MÜLLER; D. WEE; R. HENSLEY; M. GUAN; T. MÖLLER; G. ECKHARD; G. BRAY; S. BEIKER; A. BROTSCHI; D. KOHLER, (2016). Automotive Revolution—Perspective Towards (2030). McKinsey&Company (Advanced Industries). Available online at https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/McKinsey/Industries/ Automotive%20and%20Assembly/Our%20Insights/Disruptive%20trends%20that%20will%2 0transform%20the%20auto%20industry/Auto%202030%20report%20Jan%202016.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  16. KALETA, P., (2020). Überraschender Erfolg in Berlin: Volkswagen expandiert in einem Bereich, aus dem sich Daimler und BMW gerade zurückziehen. In Business Insider, 2020. Available online at https://www.businessinsider.de/wirtschaft/mobility/weshare-vw-sehr-zufrieden-mit-erfolg- von-carsharingdienst-in-berlin-a/, checked on 1/21/2021.
  17. KEMPF, S.; B. HEID; A. PADHI; A. TSCHIESNER; A. CORNET; D. MOHR; G. CAMPLONE; T. NAUCLÉR; T. BAUMGARTNER; R. HANSER, (2018). Ready for Inspection. The Automotive Aftermarket in 2030. McKinsey Center For Furture Mobility. Available online at https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/McKinsey/Industries/ Automotive%20and%20Assembly/Our%20Insights/Ready%20for%20inspection%20The%20a utomotive%20aftermarket%20in%202030/Ready-for-inspection-The-automotive-aftermarket- in-2030-vF.ashx, checked on 1/21/2021.
  18. KOPP, J. P., (2015). GPS-gestützte Evaluation des Mobilitätsverhaltens von free-floating CarSharing- Nutzern. Diss. Nr. 22577 ETH Zürich. S.l.: s.n.
  19. KUHNERT, F.; C. STÜRMER; A. KOSTER, (2018). Five Trends Transforming the Automotive Industry. PwC. Available online at https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/industries/automotive/assets/pwc-five- trends-transforming-the-automotive-industry.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  20. KUMARASWAMI, A.; R. GARUD; S. ANSARI, (2018). Perspectives on Disruptive Innovations. In Journal of Management Studies, 1025–1042.
  21. MORTSIEFER, H., (2020). Streit über Parkgebühren. Berlin überlässt Carsharing-Firmen in der Krises ich selbst. In Der Tagesspiegel, (2020). Available online at https://www.tagesspiegel.de/wirtschaft/streit-ueber-parkgebuehren-berlin-ueberlaesst- carsharing-firmen-in-der-krise-sich-selbst/25827518.html, checked on 1/21/2021.
  22. No Name, (2018). Financial year 2017: car2go grows significantly and strengthens its market leadership. Car2Go. Available online at https://www.car2go.com/media/data/na/press/releases/financial-year.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  23. No Name, (2019a). Bevölkerung am 31.12.2019 nach Alter, Geschlecht und Migrationshintergrund. Available online at https:// www.muenchen.de/rathaus/dam/jcr:ab9fa157-c362-4a23-90fd- a79f6d0a92fa/jt200103.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  24. No Name, (2019b). Carsharing Market & Growth Analysis 2019. Movmi. Available online at https://movmi.net/carsharing-market-growth-2019/, checked on 1/21/2021.
  25. No Name, 2019c. HERE Erreichbarkeit Analyse. HERE Global B.V. Available online at https://go.engage.here.com/rs/142-UEL- 347/images/20191018_HERE_Erreichbarkeit_Analyse_Charts-2.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  26. No Name, (2019d). More Members, More rentals: car2go has successful financial year 2018. Car2Go. Available online at https://www.car2go.com/media/data/na/press/releases/011019_press- release_car2go-2018-success_na.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  27. No Name, 2019e. Share Now: Facts And Figures. ShareNow. Available online at https://content.drive-now.com/sites/default/files/images/201911_SHARE%20NOW_Factsheet_DE_0.pdf, updated on 1/21/(2021).
  28. No Name, (2020). Entwicklung des Kraftfahrzeugbestands. In Rathaus Umschau 95, 2020. Available online at https://ru.muenchen.de/2020/95/Entwicklung-des-Kraftfahrzeug bestands-91203, checked on 1/21/2021.
  29. No Name, 2021a. Aktuelle Zahlen und Fakten zum CarSharing in Deutschland. bcs. Available online at https://carsharing.de/alles-ueber-carsharing/carsharing-zahlen/aktuelle-zahlen-daten-zum- carsharing-deutschland, checked on 1/21/2021.
  30. No Name, 2021b. Getaround Connect verstehen. Getaround SAS. Available online at https://de.getaround.com/help/articles/445c28d4003f#owners, checked on 1/21/2021.
  31. No Name, 2021c. Kenne deinen Wert und verhandle richtig. XING kununu Prescreen GmbH. Available online at https://www.kununu.com/de/share-now/gehalt, checked on 1/21/(2021).
  32. No Name, 2021d. Share Now: Facts And Figures. ShareNow. Available online at https://brandhub.share-now.com/web/6570a0eb69e15b2f/factsheets/?mediaId=CC46F201- 42CB-44A8-9756911BF0D3F5EB, checked on 1/21/2021.
  33. REA, B.; S. STACHURA; LAURIN WALLACE; D. M. PANKTRATZ, (2017). Making the Future of Mobility Work. Deloitte (Deloitte Review, 21). Available online at https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/cn/Documents/cip/deloitte-cn-cip-making- future-of-mobility-work-en-171214.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  34. RUHRORT, L., (2020). Nutzungsmuster von Carsharing im Kontext von Strategien nachhaltiger Mobilität. Eine Untersuchung am Beispiel von "WeShare"-Carsharing auf Basis von Nutzer*innenbefragungen und Buchungsdaten. Berlin: Wissenschaftszentrum Berlin für Sozialforschung gGmbH (Discussion paper / WZB, Wissenschaftszentrum Berlin für Sozialforschung, SP III (2020), 604).
  35. SCHILLER, T.; T. POTTENBAUM; J. SCHEIDL, (2017). Car Sharing in Europe: Business Models, National Variations and Upcoming Disruptions. Deloitte. Available online at https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/de/Documents/consumer-industrial- products/CIP-Automotive-Car-Sharing-in-Europe.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  36. SCOTT, C.; D. M. PANKRATZ, (2017). Forces of Change: The Future of Mobility. Deloitte (Deloitte Insights). Available online at https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/insights/us/articles/4328_Forces-of- change_FoM/DI_Forces-of-change_FoM.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  37. STOLLE, W.; W. STEINMANN; V. RODEWYK; A. R. GIL; A. PEINE, (2019). The demystification of car sharing. Kearney. Available online at https://www.de.kearney.com/documents/20152/4956327/The+ Demystification+of+Car+Sharing+LOCKED.pdf/75a854a0-54e9-3905-1713-2d0a46576 ae5?t =1567487593856, checked on 1/21/2021.
  38. SWISHER, K., (2019). Owning a Car Will Soon Be as Quaint as Owning a Horse. In The New York Times, (2019). Available online at https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/22/opinion/end-of-cars- uber-lyft.html, checked on 1/21/2021.
  39. WEBER, H.; T. KRONEN; S. JURSCH; C. von HEIMENDAHL, (2018). Transforming vehicle production by 2030. how shared mobility and automation will revolutionize the auto industry. PwC. Available online at https://www.strategyand.pwc.com/de/en/industries/automotive/transforming- vehicle-production/transforming-vehicle-production.pdf, checked on 1/21/2021.
  40. WEIDENBACH, B., (2021). Bruttowerbeaufwendungen von BMW in Deutschland bis 2020. Statista. Available online at https://de.statista.com/prognosen/1176028/bruttowerbeaufwendungen- von-bmw, checked on 1/21/2021.
  41. WEIMER, M., (2016). Diese Umfrage zeigt, wer Carsharing wirklich nutzt. Business Insider Deutschland GmbH. Available online at https://www.businessinsider.de/gruenderszene/allgemein/carsharing-umfrage-forsa-nutzer/, checked on 1/21/2021.